Docket Sheet

Alex Belfi v. City of Philadelphia Law Department

OOR Dkt. No.: AP 2024-2356
Case Status: Pending in Common Pleas

10/09/2024

09/20/2024

Similo, Erika

Philadelphia

Request sought emails and other records pertaining to identified properties located within the City. The City provided responsive records on appeal. The City reasonably interpreted the portion of Item 2 Request seeking records other than emails. The Request is insufficiently specific in part, but the City did not demonstrate that the portion of Item 2 of the Request seeking emails is insufficiently specific. The City did not demonstrate that it searched for all possible records responsive to Item 3 of the Request or that no responsive records exist within its possession, custody or control. The record does not support a finding of bad faith. Granted in part, denied in part and dismissed as moot in part.

Clause Exemption Result
Agency Invoked an Extension The agency invoked a 30 day extension to respond to the request.
Deemed Denial Request was deemed denied.
Dismissed as moot Dismissed as moot
Not in Possession, Custody, or Control of Agency Not in Possession, Custody, or Control of Agency Granted
Section 703 - Specificity Section 703 - Specificity Partially Granted
Docket Entries
Filed Description Step Court Document
04/08/2025 Requester Brief Court Filing Court of Common Pleas (24-10-03682)
04/07/2025 Agency Brief Court Filing Court of Common Pleas (24-10-03627)
03/03/2025 Court Order Granting Relief Court Filing Court of Common Pleas (24-10-03682)
03/03/2025 Agency Joint Motion For Relief Court Filing Court of Common Pleas (24-10-03682)
03/03/2025 Agency Entry of Appearance Court Filing Court of Common Pleas (24-10-03682)
01/31/2025 Court Order Consolidating Appeals Court Filing Court of Common Pleas (24-10-03627)
01/30/2025 OOR Certified Record Court Filing Court of Common Pleas (24-10-03682)
01/30/2025 OOR Certified Record Court Filing Court of Common Pleas (24-10-03627)
12/12/2024 Court Writ of Certiorari Court Filing Court of Common Pleas (24-10-03627)
12/12/2024 Court Writ of Certiorari Court Filing Court of Common Pleas (24-10-03682)
10/28/2024 Court Notice of Filing Appeal Court Filing Court of Common Pleas (24-10-03627)
10/28/2024 Agency Notice of Appeal Court Filing Court of Common Pleas (24-10-03627)
10/29/2024 Court Notice of Filing Appeal Court Filing Court of Common Pleas (24-10-03682)
10/28/2024 Requester Notice of Appeal Court Filing Court of Common Pleas (24-10-03682)
10/01/2024 OOR Final Determination Final Determination
Print Docket Sheet