Final Determination Record

Shannon v. City of Philadelphia Commerce Department

OOR Dkt. No.: AP 2018-0460
Case Status: Remanded

Philadelphia

Request for Amazon proposal. Agency did not prove that the proposal constitutes confidential proprietary information or a trade secret. Agency did not prove that the proposal contains exempt real estate evaluations. Agency did not prove that the proposal reflects the strategy to achieve the successful adoption of a budget or a legislative proposal. Agency did not prove that the proposal was submitted to an agency regarding procurement. Granted.

  • Section 708(a) - Agency Failed to meet burden
  • The agency invoked a 30 day extension to respond to the request.

Filings Received by OOR
Filed Adjudicator Description or File Name Document
04/26/2018 2018-0460_Shannon_PhilaDeptCommerce_FD.pdf
10/15/2018 Philadelphia Court of Common Pleas Direct Interest Participate filed Brief
10/16/2018 Philadelphia Court of Common Pleas Brief in Support_DIP
10/17/2018 Philadelphia Court of Common Pleas Entry of Appearance_Agency
10/17/2018 Philadelphia Court of Common Pleas Court Order_Consolidating Appeals
11/02/2018 Philadelphia Court of Common Pleas Entry of Appearance_Agency
11/05/2018 Philadelphia Court of Common Pleas Court Opinion_Remanded
05/25/2018 Philadelphia Court of Common Pleas City of Phila. Mayor's Office filed Notice of Appeal against Shannon (02926)
05/25/2018 Philadelphia Court of Common Pleas City of Phila. Dept of Commerce filed Notice of Appeal against Shannon (02928)
05/25/2018 Philadelphia Court of Common Pleas Phila. Industrial Dev Corp. filed Notice of Appeal against Shannon and City of Phila, Dept of Commerce (02800)
05/25/2018 Philadelphia Court of Common Pleas Phila Industrial Dev Corp. filed Notice of Appeal against Shannon and City of Phila Mayor's Office (02805)
07/13/2018 Philadelphia Court of Common Pleas Court Amended Notice - Hearing
07/13/2018 Philadelphia Court of Common Pleas Court Notice - Hearing or Argument
08/07/2018 Supreme Court Application for Extraordinary Relief
08/22/2018 Philadelphia Court of Common Pleas Court Notice - Hearing or Argument Rescheduled
08/27/2018 Philadelphia Court of Common Pleas Motion to Supplement the Record
09/06/2018 Philadelphia Court of Common Pleas OOR Certified Record
09/06/2018 Philadelphia Court of Common Pleas OOR Certified Record_Part2
09/06/2018 Philadelphia Court of Common Pleas OOR Certified Record_Part3
09/17/2018 Philadelphia Court of Common Pleas Brief in Support of Motion to Supplement the Record
09/17/2018 Philadelphia Court of Common Pleas Brief in Opposition_PIDC
09/21/2018 Philadelphia Court of Common Pleas Entry of Appearance
09/21/2018 Philadelphia Court of Common Pleas Motion to Consolidate
10/01/2018 Philadelphia Court of Common Pleas Brief in Support
10/11/2018 Philadelphia Court of Common Pleas Court Order- Granting Motion to Supplement the Record
10/15/2018 Philadelphia Court of Common Pleas Brief in Support